The Climate Underground

I just returned from a conference at Al Gore’s farm in Carthage, Tennessee, where about 300 stakeholders gathered to discuss the contributions of farming to rising carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and what we can do about it. Currently, our food system is responsible for about 30% of the nation’s carbon dioxide emissions, and activities on farms account for about one third of that. The ground was fertile with ideas from scientists, farmers, chefs, food system entrepreneurs, and others. The vegetarian lunches at the conference were supplied by local and organic produce—to the inspiration and enjoyment of all.

Everyone agreed that building soil organic matter was good for farming. It improves soil texture and its ability to hold water and nutrients. Often we can build soil organic matter by less intensive farming practices, including no-till, and reductions in the use of artificial fertilizers. Reduced tillage lowers carbon dioxide emissions from farm equipment, and less fertilizer will lower the emissions of nitrous oxide—another greenhouse gas—to the atmosphere. Minimizing the time that fields are bare by planting “cover crops” is also useful. Organic farming practices build soil organic matter, although crop yields are often lower, so more land needs to be cultivated. See: https://blogs.nicholas.duke.edu/citizenscientist/organic-foods-who-couldnt-like-them/

Some actions to increase soil organic matter are themselves a source of atmospheric carbon dioxide emissions, including the use of fertilizer and most instances of irrigation. Applications of biochar and ground silicates to agricultural soils result in only small uptake or storage of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Applications of manure to farmland are helpful to the disposal of this animal waste and to reducing emissions of methane, but they merely redistribute the organic inputs that would otherwise be added to the soil on grazing lands.

Conference participants agreed that improved farming practices, such as reduced tillage, may offer some small reductions in carbon dioxide emissions to the atmosphere. Better farming practices may also retain some soil carbon that might otherwise be in the atmosphere where it affects climate. There are lots of reasons why greater levels of soil organic matter are beneficial. However, net uptake of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere in soils is likely to be trivial, so we can’t count on better management of soils to solve the climate crisis. If want to get serious about reducing carbon dioxide concentrations in the atmosphere, we must get serious about cutting carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuels.

References

Blanco-Canqui, H., C.A. Francis, and T.D. Galusha. 2017. Does organic farming accumulate carbon in deeper soil profiles in the long term? Geoderma 288: 213-221.

Schlesinger, W.H. 2017. See: https://blogs.nicholas.duke.edu/citizenscientist/whats-new-down-on-the-farm/

Schlesinger, W.H. and Ron Amundson. 2018. Managing for Soil Carbon Sequestration: Let’s get realistic. Global Change Biology https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.14478

Seufert, V., N. Ramankutty and J.A. Foley. 2012. Comparing the yields of organic and conventional agriculture. Nature 485: 229-232.

Smith, G.G., G.J.D. Kirk, P.J. Jones, and A.G. Williams. 2019. The greenhouse gas impacts of converting food production in England and Wales to organic methods. Nature Communications 10: doi: 10.1038/s41467-019-12622-7

One thought on “The Climate Underground

  1. As a practicing lawyer, I have always marveled at how tax policy and the tax avoidance planning of clients to minimize tax impacts ends up distorting the original purpose for which the client came to my office. In this discussion of agricultural techniques, I would counsel that we not forget that the purpose of farming is to feed humans and the animals which serve them, not to change the CO2 percentages in the atmosphere. CO2 is only one element of global warming and climate change. CO2 reduction is not the silver bullet. Rather a comprehensive plan of how to adjust to the natural cycle of global warming and cooling should not be lost in the rush to slow human contribution to it. Nor should we forget the myriad other extremely damaging environmental problems created by human activity on this Earth. Just some thoughts.

Leave a Reply