Let there be darkness

As primates, humans evolved as a daylight species.  In the developed world, we now regularly subject ourselves to longer days through artificial lighting. Nights are also destined to become brighter as energy-saving LED lights replace the incandescent streetlights of Thomas Edison.  As with the addition of novel substances to our air and water, the addition of light to the environment can be regarded as a pollutant. Indeed, documentation of the effects of light pollution are accumulating so rapidly that the subject now has its own acronym—ALAN—for artificial light at night.  I have blogged on the impacts of light pollution before; this is an update.  See: http://blogs.nicholas.duke.edu/citizenscientist/is-it-better-to-light-a-single-candle-than-to-curse-the-darkness/

It is not surprising that many of the first studies of light pollution focused on migratory birds, which normally use astronomical light to orient their travel.  As the night sky becomes brighter, birds get disoriented.   Many are attracted to urban areas, and a significant number succumb to collisions with tall skyscrapers and radio towers that are lighted at night.  As roads proliferate on the landscape, streetlights do as well.  We are converting much of our habitat to a world of 24-hour activity.

Studies of birds also show disruptions of normal sleep patterns, increased vulnerability to predators, and increasing chemical levels in blood, such as oxalate, that indicate stress.  It is the latter that should concern us all.  Changes in the levels of endocrine hormones in the blood are associated with cancers in humans. The birds are telling us something.

Recent studies have shown strong correlations between breast and prostate cancer, night-time work and blood hormone levels in humans.  One study of nurses suggests that sustained night-shift work may increase the risk of breast cancer by 50 to 100%, associated with the suppression of melatonin and disruption of Circadian rhythms. Across 110 countries worldwide, ALAN explained 79% of the variability in the occurrence prostate cancer.

As with so many studies of occupational effects on health, controlled experiments are difficult to organize—the effects are long-term, we can’t control the subjects, and other factors confound the results.   Nevertheless, the increasing reports of hormonal disruption in birds and humans subject to artificial light at night are increasing cause for concern.

Darkness may be our friend.

 

References

Horton, B.M. and 5 others. 2017.  High-intensity urban light installation dramatically alters nocturnal bird migration.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences doi: 10.1073/pnas.1708574114

Quyang, J.Q and 7 others. 2017.  Restless roots: Light pollution affects behavior, sleep, and physiology in a free-living songbird.  Global Change Biology doi: 10.1111/gcb.13756

Rybnikovaa, N.N., A. Haimb, and B.A. Portnova. 2017.  Is prostate cancer incidence worldwide linked to artificial light at night exposures: Review of earlier findings and analysis of current trends.  Archives of Environmental and Occupational Health 72: 111-122.

Touitou, Y., A. Reinberg, and D. Touitou. 2017.  Association between light at night, melatonin secretion, sleep deprivation, and the internal clock. Health impacts and mechanisms of circadian disruption.  Life Sciences 173: 94-106.

Zielinska-Dabkowska. K.M. 2018. Make lighting healthier.  Nature 553: 272-276.

One thought on “Let there be darkness

  1. For those interested in better lighting practices, the International Dark Sky Society has information at http://www.darksky.org/lighting/lighting-basics/. Model ordinances for those communities who respect best practices and want to promote efficient and healthier lighting are offered by the society.

    Unfortunately, our Rural Electric Administration’s electric membership co-ops seem to make no effort to advance and promote downward directed night lights with cut-outs to stop light trespass. Overlamped fixtures with no shields are their usual leased lighting installs–symbols of waste and bad neighbors. Same for the for-profit utilities. With efficient LED lights being inherently directional, it could be easier to limit light trespass and light pollution with proper fixture selection. But some people and some institutions have no concern for others or the environment–especially utilities.

    Lighting spectrum is the other concern here-seems blue white light is especially harmful. A lot of research is being published inn that area. With our corneas being a most sensitive and unprotected tissue, we may find eye problems, such as cataracts–which are tied to light and EMF exposure–become a growing health concern.

    For more on the harms to birds, the documentary The Messenger is highly recommended. More on that at songbirdsos.com

Leave a Reply